Skip to content

Services · Restorative · Extractions

Tooth extractions in Johnstown, NY.

Sometimes a tooth genuinely cannot be saved. We perform simple extractions calmly and conservatively, and we talk through every alternative before recommending one. Complex surgical extractions and wisdom teeth are referred to a trusted local oral surgeon.

Dr. D'Addio reassuring a patient about an upcoming extraction at Dunning Family Dental in Johnstown, NY.

Only when nothing else works.

We try repair, root canal, crown, or watchful waiting before extraction. When a tooth has to come out, the visit is brief and the recovery is straightforward.

Most extractions: under 30 minutes

When a tooth has to come out

When extraction is the right call.

We work to save every tooth that can be saved. These are the situations where extraction is actually the better outcome.

Severe decay below the gum line

When decay extends so far below the gum that no crown can grip the remaining tooth and no root canal can save the pulp, extraction is more honest than a doomed restoration.

A tooth cracked into the root

Cracks that travel below the gum line into the root structure usually mean the tooth can't be predictably repaired. Extraction and a replacement plan (implant or bridge) is the longer-term answer.

Advanced gum disease

When periodontal disease has destroyed too much of the bone supporting a tooth, the tooth becomes loose and infected. Extraction protects the surrounding teeth and resolves the infection.

A failed root canal that can't be retreated

Most root canals last decades, but some fail. When retreatment isn't an option (anatomy, posts in place, structural compromise), extraction is the responsible next step.

What we do

Simple in-house. Complex referred.

There's a real distinction between simple and surgical extractions. Knowing where the line is, and being willing to refer, matters more than doing everything ourselves.

Simple extractions

Visible, fully erupted teeth without unusual root anatomy. Done at Dunning with local anesthetic.

Pre-extraction planning

We discuss replacement options before the tooth comes out, implant restoration, bridge, partial denture, or leaving the space, so you can plan around it.

Surgical extractions

Impacted teeth, broken roots, or anything requiring sedation gets referred to a trusted local oral surgeon. We coordinate the referral.

Wisdom teeth

Wisdom tooth removal is referred to oral surgery. We evaluate when wisdom teeth need to come out vs being left alone and watched.

Post-extraction care

Clear written instructions for the first days of healing, and a return visit if needed.

Replacement coordination

If the plan is an implant restoration or bridge, we time the next steps to match healing, and coordinate with the oral surgeon if implant placement is involved.

What to expect

Calm, brief, and predictable.

A simple extraction is usually a single, short appointment. Recovery is usually measured in days, not weeks.

  1. 1

    Numbing + assessment

    Topical gel, then local anesthetic. Dr. D'Addio confirms the tooth is fully numb before any procedure starts.

  2. 2

    Gentle extraction

    The tooth is loosened from its socket and removed with steady, controlled pressure. You feel pressure but no sharp pain. Once the area is numb, a simple extraction is usually quick.

  3. 3

    Aftercare instructions

    Gauze on the socket, written instructions, a list of what to expect over 48 hours, and the office phone number for any concerns. You can drive yourself home from a simple extraction.

Insurance and cost

Using your benefits out of network.

Dunning is a fee-for-service practice. That does not mean you cannot use dental benefits here. Many patients do. You pay the practice at the visit, we submit the claim to most carriers as a courtesy, and your insurer sends reimbursement directly to you. Card, check, cash, HSA and FSA cards, and CareCredit are accepted. Medicaid and Fidelis are not.

See how insurance works here

Your plan, looked up first

Before work beyond a basic exam or cleaning, the front desk checks your plan and gives you a written estimate.

Claims filed as a courtesy

We submit the claim for you. Your insurer applies your plan's rules and makes the final benefit determination.

Common extraction questions

Questions about tooth extractions?

Does a tooth extraction hurt?
The actual procedure should not hurt. Local anesthetic numbs the tooth, gum, and bone around it completely. You feel pressure as the tooth is loosened, but not sharp pain. If you do feel anything sharp during the procedure, tell Dr. D'Addio immediately and we'll add more anesthetic before continuing. After the numbness wears off, soreness for the first day or two is normal and is usually manageable with over-the-counter pain relief as directed. Pain that's increasing rather than decreasing after 48 hours, or pain that doesn't respond to over-the-counter medication, should be called in. It can signal dry socket or infection, both of which we treat.
How long does it take to recover from a tooth extraction?
After a simple extraction, most of the soreness usually fades within a few days. The first 24 hours: avoid spitting, rinsing, smoking, or using a straw, as suction can dislodge the blood clot forming in the socket. Eat soft foods (yogurt, scrambled eggs, soup that isn't hot) on the side opposite the extraction. Take ibuprofen or acetaminophen as needed for soreness. After the first day: gentle saltwater rinses begin, you can start eating more normally on the other side, and the soreness should be steadily decreasing. The bone in the socket takes weeks to fill in, but you will feel normal long before that. If an implant is planned for that space, the timing is set with the oral surgeon based on how the site heals.
What should I do after a tooth extraction?
First 24 hours: bite firmly on the gauze as directed after leaving the office to control bleeding, then change gauze if needed for another 30 minutes. Don't rinse, spit, smoke, or use straws. Suction can break the protective blood clot. Eat soft, room-temperature foods. Take ibuprofen or acetaminophen per the dosing instructions we provide. Use an ice pack on the outside of your cheek for 15-minute intervals to reduce swelling. Sleep with your head elevated. After 24 hours: start gentle saltwater rinses a few times a day, especially after meals. Brush other teeth as normal but avoid the extraction site. Call the office if bleeding doesn't stop after a few hours, if pain increases after day 2, or if you develop fever or significant swelling.
How much does a tooth extraction cost in Johnstown?
Simple extraction fees vary by tooth and complexity but typically sit in the lower range of restorative procedures, significantly less than crowns, root canals, or implants. Before any extraction, the front desk gives you a written estimate showing the practice fee and the portion your insurance is expected to reimburse if you have a plan. Surgical extractions referred to the oral surgeon are billed separately by their office under their fee schedule. The insurance and payment page explains how billing and CareCredit work. Call (518) 842-3220 with your specific tooth for an honest estimate.
Do I need to replace the tooth after extraction?
Not always, but often the answer is yes if you want to keep your bite, your other teeth, and your jaw healthy long-term. When a tooth is missing, adjacent teeth slowly drift into the space, the opposing tooth can over-erupt, and the bone in the empty socket shrinks over time. Whether to replace depends on which tooth is missing, your age, the cost, and how the missing tooth affects chewing and appearance. Options include an implant restoration (requires healing time and an oral surgeon referral), a bridge (faster, requires altering neighboring teeth), or a partial denture. We discuss all three honestly before the extraction so you can plan. If the missing tooth is a back wisdom tooth or a tooth that's been gone for years already, replacement may not be necessary.
What's the difference between a simple and a surgical extraction?
A simple extraction is for a fully erupted, visible tooth with normal root anatomy. Dr. D'Addio can grip the visible crown of the tooth, loosen it from the socket, and remove it in one piece. These are done at Dunning with local anesthetic. A surgical extraction is required for impacted teeth (wisdom teeth that haven't fully erupted), teeth that have broken off at the gum line, teeth with unusual or hooked roots, or any extraction where the patient needs sedation. Surgical extractions involve a small incision, sometimes sectioning the tooth into pieces, and often require stitches. These are referred to a trusted local oral surgeon. Dunning coordinates the referral, sends the X-rays and chart notes, and is involved in any follow-up restorative work afterward.
Do you remove wisdom teeth?
Wisdom tooth removal is referred to a trusted oral surgeon. Dunning evaluates whether wisdom teeth need to come out or can be left alone and watched, and coordinates the referral when removal is the right call.
Will you file my dental insurance for an extraction?
Yes, as a courtesy. Dunning is fee-for-service and out of network, so you pay the practice at the visit and we submit the claim to most carriers for you. Your insurer applies your plan's rules and sends any reimbursement directly to you. Before treatment beyond a basic exam or cleaning, the front desk gives you a written estimate. It is a good-faith approximation; your insurer makes the final benefit determination. Medicaid and Fidelis are not accepted.

Save the tooth when you can.

Call (518) 842-3220 and we'll honestly evaluate whether the tooth can be saved before recommending extraction.

Dunning Family Dental 310 Jansen Avenue Johnstown, NY 12095 (518) 842-3220

Honest dentistry for families who want the long view.

Call (518) 842-3220 Request a visit